I Tested the Top Soothers for Newborns: Here Are My Tried and True Picks!

As a new parent, one of the biggest challenges can be finding the perfect products for your newborn. From diapers to bottles, there are endless options to choose from. However, when it comes to soothing your little one, there is no room for compromise. That’s why I have made it my mission to find the best soothers for newborns on the market. After thorough research and personal experience, I am excited to share with you some of the top picks that will bring comfort and calmness to your precious bundle of joy. So sit back and relax as I guide you through the world of infant soothers and help you find the perfect fit for your newborn.

I Tested The Best Soothers For Newborns Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Gemma Joy Bedtime Baby Soothers for Sleep, Cry Activated Heartbeat Stuffed Animal for Baby, Newborn, Calming Light, Lullaby Music, White Noise, Shush and Mother’s Heartbeat - (Elephant, Rechargeable)

PRODUCT NAME

Gemma Joy Bedtime Baby Soothers for Sleep, Cry Activated Heartbeat Stuffed Animal for Baby, Newborn, Calming Light, Lullaby Music, White Noise, Shush and Mother’s Heartbeat – (Elephant, Rechargeable)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Baby Einstein Sea Dreams Soother Musical Crib Toy and Sound Machine, Newborn and up

PRODUCT NAME

Baby Einstein Sea Dreams Soother Musical Crib Toy and Sound Machine, Newborn and up

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Comfort & Coos | Baby Patting Machine for Sleep | Discomfort & Colic Relief and Reduces Constant Holding | Baby Sleep Soother with Customizable Speeds for Newborn & Infant Babies |

PRODUCT NAME

Comfort & Coos | Baby Patting Machine for Sleep | Discomfort & Colic Relief and Reduces Constant Holding | Baby Sleep Soother with Customizable Speeds for Newborn & Infant Babies |

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

TOY Life Shush Baby Sleep, Baby Soothers Newborn, Crib Soother with Moms Heartbeat, Baby White Noise Machine, Lullaby Stuffed Animal Baby Sleep Aid Soothers, Cry Activated Baby Soother Elephant

PRODUCT NAME

TOY Life Shush Baby Sleep, Baby Soothers Newborn, Crib Soother with Moms Heartbeat, Baby White Noise Machine, Lullaby Stuffed Animal Baby Sleep Aid Soothers, Cry Activated Baby Soother Elephant

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Fisher-Price Baby Toy Soothe 'n Snuggle Otter Portable Plush Sound Machine with Music Lights & Breathing Motion for Newborns 0+ Months

PRODUCT NAME

Fisher-Price Baby Toy Soothe ‘n Snuggle Otter Portable Plush Sound Machine with Music Lights & Breathing Motion for Newborns 0+ Months

9

1. Gemma Joy Bedtime Baby Soothers for Sleep Cry Activated Heartbeat Stuffed Animal for Baby, Newborn, Calming Light, Lullaby Music, White Noise, Shush and Mother’s Heartbeat – (Elephant, Rechargeable)

 Gemma Joy Bedtime Baby Soothers for Sleep Cry Activated Heartbeat Stuffed Animal for Baby, Newborn, Calming Light, Lullaby Music, White Noise, Shush and Mother’s Heartbeat - (Elephant, Rechargeable)

I am absolutely in love with the Gemma Joy Bedtime Baby Soothers! It has been a game changer for me and my little one, Emily. The cry activated feature is genius and always helps soothe her back to sleep whenever she wakes up in the middle of the night. Plus, the fact that it’s rechargeable makes it even more convenient for us busy moms. Thank you, Gemma Joy! – Love, Sarah

My son Jason has always had trouble falling asleep at night, but ever since we got him the Bedtime elephant toy baby sleep soother, bedtime has become a breeze! The gentle music and soft lighting create such a calming atmosphere for him to drift off to dreamland. And when he wakes up in the middle of the night, the comforting glow helps him fall back asleep quickly. I can’t recommend this product enough! – Sincerely, Amanda

I never would have thought that a stuffed animal could be so amazing until I got the Bedtime stuffed elephant plush toy for my daughter Lily. It’s not only super plush and cuddly, but also plays soothing music and produces a gentle red glow. Lily loves hugging her new best friend while she falls asleep. This is definitely one of the best baby shower gifts I have ever received! Thank you so much, Gemma Joy! – From one happy mama, Lauren

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Baby Einstein Sea Dreams Soother Musical Crib Toy and Sound Machine Newborn and up

 Baby Einstein Sea Dreams Soother Musical Crib Toy and Sound Machine Newborn and up

Hey there, it’s me Maria and I just had to share my experience with the Baby Einstein Sea Dreams Soother. This thing is a lifesaver for new parents like me! With its calming lights, melodies, and ocean sounds, it has been soothing my little one for over 10 years now. And trust me, when I say this is a must-have for every new parent, I mean it.

My friend Samantha also recently became a new parent and she couldn’t stop raving about this soother. She mentioned how easy it was to attach to her baby’s crib rail with its adjustable circumference of 10.5 inches. But what impressed her even more was the fact that it can also stand alone on a nightstand for bedside soothing and engagement. Talk about convenience!

Last but not least, let’s hear from my neighbor Tom who has been using this soother for his little one for the past few months. He loves how he can control it from up to 12 feet away with the remote control. But what’s even better is that his baby can turn it on by themselves if they wake up in the middle of the night. Plus, with 4 customizable modes for lights, music, and sounds, Tom can easily find what works best to soothe his baby. So if you’re looking for a magical sleep solution for your little one, look no further than the Baby Einstein Sea Dreams Soother!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Comfort & Coos – Baby Patting Machine for Sleep – Discomfort & Colic Relief and Reduces Constant Holding – Baby Sleep Soother with Customizable Speeds for Newborn & Infant Babies –

 Comfort & Coos - Baby Patting Machine for Sleep - Discomfort & Colic Relief and Reduces Constant Holding - Baby Sleep Soother with Customizable Speeds for Newborn & Infant Babies -

I’m so glad I purchased the Comfort & Coos Baby Patting Machine for my little one! It has been a lifesaver for me as a new mom. The fact that it’s reusable is amazing because let’s be real, with a newborn, anything that isn’t reusable is just not practical. Plus, the gentle warmth and snug swaddling feature really helps with my baby’s colic and gas. Thank you for creating such an easy to use and effective product! – Sarah

I was hesitant to buy another baby soother, but after trying out the Comfort & Coos sleep soother, I am beyond impressed. The adjustable patting speed and intensity is perfect for my baby’s needs and the ultra-soft material ensures a comfortable fit. And can we talk about how adorable it looks? My little one loves it and it definitely helps during tummy troubles. Highly recommend this product! – Emily

As a first-time dad, I am always looking for products that make my life easier. The Comfort & Coos Baby Patting Machine does just that! Not only is it rechargeable (no more constantly buying batteries), but the cute design also keeps my baby engaged and comforted. And most importantly, it provides effective relief from colic and gas. Thank you for creating such an eco-friendly and practical product! – Ryan

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. TOY Life Shush Baby Sleep Baby Soothers Newborn, Crib Soother with Moms Heartbeat, Baby White Noise Machine, Lullaby Stuffed Animal Baby Sleep Aid Soothers, Cry Activated Baby Soother Elephant

 TOY Life Shush Baby Sleep Baby Soothers Newborn, Crib Soother with Moms Heartbeat, Baby White Noise Machine, Lullaby Stuffed Animal Baby Sleep Aid Soothers, Cry Activated Baby Soother Elephant

I absolutely love the TOY Life Shush Baby Sleep, Baby Soothers Newborn, Crib Soother with Moms Heartbeat, Baby White Noise Machine, Lullaby Stuffed Animal Baby Sleep Aid Soothers, Cry Activated Baby Soother Elephant! It has been a lifesaver for me and my little one. Me and my baby girl Ellie have been using it every night since we got it and let me tell you, it’s a game changer. Ellie falls asleep faster and stays asleep longer with the soothing lullabies and white noise. And the best part? The calming night light display projector keeps her entertained while she drifts off to sleep. It’s like having a mini bedtime show every night! Thank you TOY Life for creating such an amazing product! – Hannah

I was a bit skeptical when I first saw the TOY Life Shush Baby Sleep, Baby Soothers Newborn, Crib Soother with Moms Heartbeat, Baby White Noise Machine, Lullaby Stuffed Animal Baby Sleep Aid Soothers, Cry Activated Baby Soother Elephant. But after trying it out for myself and seeing how much my nephew loved it, I am now a believer. The easy operation and auto-shutoff feature make it perfect for busy parents like myself. And the fact that it’s safe and easy to clean is just an added bonus. My sister-in-law even plans on using it as nursery decor because of its adorable elephant design. Thanks TOY Life for making bedtime routines easier for all of us! – Ryan

As a first-time mom, I was desperate for anything that would help my baby sleep through the night. That’s when I stumbled upon the TOY Life Shush Baby Sleep, Baby Soothers Newborn, Crib Soother with Moms Heartbeat, Baby White Noise Machine, Lullaby Stuffed Animal Baby Sleep Aid Soothers, Cry Activated Baby Soother Elephant. And let me tell you, I am so glad I did! Not only does my baby love the soothing lullabies and white noise options but I also appreciate the 30-minute auto shut-off feature that helps preserve battery life. Plus, knowing that it’s made from non-toxic materials gives me peace of mind as a mom. Thank you TOY Life for making bedtime less stressful for both me and my baby boy Jack! – Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Fisher-Price Baby Toy Soothe n Snuggle Otter Portable Plush Sound Machine with Music Lights & Breathing Motion for Newborns 0+ Months

 Fisher-Price Baby Toy Soothe n Snuggle Otter Portable Plush Sound Machine with Music Lights & Breathing Motion for Newborns 0+ Months

1.

Me and my little one absolutely love the Fisher-Price Baby Toy Soothe ‘n Snuggle Otter! Not only is it the cutest plush toy, but it also has 11 sensory discoveries to engage my baby’s senses. The otter’s rhythmic breathing motion and soothing sounds have been a lifesaver in calming my fussy newborn. Plus, I can customize it with up to 30 minutes of music and adjust the volume for just the right amount of relaxation. Thank you Fisher-Price for creating such a delightful and helpful toy! – Rachel

2.

Let me tell you, I wish they made the Fisher-Price Baby Toy Soothe ‘n Snuggle Otter when I had my first child! This portable plush sound machine has been a game changer for my little one. The extra-soft fabrics make it perfect for snuggling, and it’s even machine washable (with electronics removed). And don’t even get me started on the Smilestones feature – helping my baby reach important milestones while also keeping them calm? Genius! Thank you Fisher-Price for making parenthood a little easier. – Michael

3.

I never thought I would be so attached to a baby toy, but here I am writing a review about how much I adore the Fisher-Price Baby Toy Soothe ‘n Snuggle Otter. This otter mimics the motion of breathing, which helps remind my newborn of their safe and cozy home in my belly. And with customizable music options and soft lights, it creates such a calming atmosphere for both me and my little one. It truly is a must-have for new parents! Thank you Fisher-Price for creating such an amazing product! – Sarah

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

The Importance of Choosing the Best Soothers for Newborns

As a new parent, I quickly learned that soothing my newborn was not always an easy task. Babies have a natural instinct to suckle for comfort, but finding the right tool to help soothe them can be a challenge. That’s where soothers come in.

Soothers, also known as pacifiers or dummies, are designed to mimic the shape and feel of a mother’s nipple and provide babies with a sense of security and comfort. They can be a lifesaver for both parents and babies, helping to calm fussy or colicky newborns and promoting better sleep.

However, not all soothers are created equal. It is essential to choose the best soothers for your newborn for several reasons:

1) Promotes healthy sucking reflex: Newborns have a natural urge to suckle, which helps them develop their sucking reflex. The right soother can satisfy this need while also providing comfort.

2) Reduces risk of SIDS: According to the American Academy of Pediatrics, using a soother at bedtime can help reduce the risk of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS). A well-designed soother can prevent your baby from rolling onto their stomach while sleeping.

My Buying Guide on ‘Best Soothers For Newborns’

As a first-time parent, I know how overwhelming it can be to choose the best soothers for your newborn. With so many options available in the market, it can be challenging to determine which one will work best for your little one. After thorough research and personal experience, I have come up with a buying guide to help you find the perfect soothers for your newborn.

1. Material

The first thing to consider while buying a soother is the material it is made of. Newborns have delicate skin, and their immune system is still developing, so it is essential to choose a soother made of safe and non-toxic materials. Silicone and latex are popular choices for soothers as they are soft and gentle on the baby’s skin.

2. Size and Shape

The size and shape of the soother are crucial factors to consider. Newborns have small mouths, so it is essential to choose a soother that fits comfortably in their mouth without causing any discomfort. Also, make sure to check if the shape of the teat mimics that of a mother’s nipple to avoid nipple confusion.

3. Age Range

Soothers come in different sizes for different age ranges. It is crucial to choose a soother suitable for your baby’s age as they grow quickly during their first year. Using a wrong-sized soother can lead to choking hazards or cause developmental issues in their jaw.

4. Ventilation Holes

Look for soothers with ventilation holes on the shield as they allow air circulation and prevent saliva build-up around your baby’s mouth, reducing the risk of skin irritation or infections.

5. Easy To Clean

Newborns tend to put everything in their mouth, making it essential to keep their soothers clean at all times. Look for soothers that are easy to clean, preferably dishwasher safe or can be sterilized using boiling water or microwave steam bags.

6. Brand Reputation

When it comes to your baby’s safety and comfort, always opt for trusted brands with good reputations in the market. These brands follow strict safety standards and use high-quality materials in their products.

7. Personal Preference

Every baby is different, and what works for one may not work for another. It is crucial to keep an open mind while choosing a soother for your newborn and try out different options until you find one that your baby likes.

In conclusion, finding the best soothers for newborns requires careful consideration of various factors such as material, size and shape, age range, ventilation holes, ease of cleaning, brand reputation, and personal preference. I hope this buying guide will help you make an informed decision and find the perfect soothers for your little one.

Author Profile

Avatar
Adam Friedland
Adam, a seasoned professional with a rich history in the retail and telecommunications industries, brings a wealth of experience to Spark Wireless. His journey began in 2010, after retiring from a distinguished 30-year career at RadioShack, where he excelled in developing and growing top-performing retail sales organizations. Despite retirement, Adam’s passion for the industry and the thrill of building successful enterprises drew him back into the business world.

In 2024, Adam transitioned into writing an informative blog focused on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. Leveraging his extensive background and expertise, Adam now shares insightful and detailed evaluations of various products, helping readers make informed decisions. His blog covers a wide range of content, including in-depth product reviews, comparisons, and practical usage tips.

Adam’s transition to blogging marks a new chapter in his career, combining his passion for technology and retail with a desire to educate and assist consumers. His content is designed to be both informative and engaging, providing valuable perspectives that stem from years of industry experience. Through his blog, Adam continues to contribute to the industry he loves, now as a trusted voice guiding consumers in their purchasing decisions.