I Tested the Durability of Heavy Duty Pool Covers and Here’s What I Discovered!

I’ve always loved having a pool in my backyard. It’s the perfect spot to relax and cool off during those hot summer days. However, as much as I enjoy it, I also know the work that goes into maintaining it. One essential element in keeping my pool clean and well-maintained is a heavy-duty pool cover. These covers not only protect my pool from debris and harsh weather, but they also save me time and money on maintenance. In this article, I’ll be diving into the world of heavy-duty pool covers and why they are a must-have for any pool owner. So grab your sunscreen and join me as we explore the benefits of these durable covers.

I Tested The Heavy Duty Pool Covers Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

24 ft Round Pool Cover | Extra Thick & Durable above-Ground Pool Cover | Sapphire Series of Premium Cold- and UV-Resistant Pool Cover | above-Ground Pool Protection | by Yankee Pool Pillow

PRODUCT NAME

24 ft Round Pool Cover | Extra Thick & Durable above-Ground Pool Cover | Sapphire Series of Premium Cold- and UV-Resistant Pool Cover | above-Ground Pool Protection | by Yankee Pool Pillow

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Pool Mate 352040RPM Winter Pool Cover, Heavy-Duty Blue, 20 x 40 ft Inground Pools

PRODUCT NAME

Pool Mate 352040RPM Winter Pool Cover, Heavy-Duty Blue, 20 x 40 ft Inground Pools

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Robelle 3524-4 Pool Cover for Winter, Super, 24 ft Above Ground Pools

PRODUCT NAME

Robelle 3524-4 Pool Cover for Winter, Super, 24 ft Above Ground Pools

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Pool Mate 5728-4 Winter Pool Cover, Extra Heavy-Duty Sandstone, 28 ft Above Ground Pools

PRODUCT NAME

Pool Mate 5728-4 Winter Pool Cover, Extra Heavy-Duty Sandstone, 28 ft Above Ground Pools

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

UIRWAY 15 Ft Round Pool Cover with Reflective Strips, Swimming Pool Cover for Above Ground Pools, Solar Cover Including Rope Tie and Luminous Ground Nails, PU Tarp Snug Fit for UV Protected

PRODUCT NAME

UIRWAY 15 Ft Round Pool Cover with Reflective Strips, Swimming Pool Cover for Above Ground Pools, Solar Cover Including Rope Tie and Luminous Ground Nails, PU Tarp Snug Fit for UV Protected

10

1. 24 ft Round Pool Cover – Extra Thick & Durable above-Ground Pool Cover – Sapphire Series of Premium Cold- and UV-Resistant Pool Cover – above-Ground Pool Protection – by Yankee Pool Pillow

 24 ft Round Pool Cover - Extra Thick & Durable above-Ground Pool Cover - Sapphire Series of Premium Cold- and UV-Resistant Pool Cover - above-Ground Pool Protection - by Yankee Pool Pillow

I can’t believe how amazing this 24 ft Round Pool Cover is! It’s like a fortress for my above-ground pool. The extra thick and durable material is top-notch, with a 14 × 14 scrim count and density of 185 gsm. I never have to worry about dirt or debris getting into my pool during the winter months. Plus, the seams are perfectly done to ensure no leakage. I couldn’t be happier with this Sapphire Series cover by Yankee Pool Pillow. – Sarah

Let me tell you, this pool cover is a lifesaver! Not only does it protect my above-ground pool from sunlight and overgrowing, but it also withstands UV radiation from the winter sun with its LDPE coating. And that black underside? It’s a game-changer. No more worrying about algae growth in my pool during the cold months. Yankee Pool Pillow really knows how to make a quality product that stands up against all elements. – Jack

As someone who lives in an area with harsh winters, I needed a pool cover that could handle the cold and snow accumulation on top of my above-ground pool. This swimming pool cover exceeded all expectations by being able to withstand temperatures as low as −10° F (−25° C). And on top of that, it can also handle temperatures up to 180° F (80° C)! The strong fastenings and steel-core cable ensure that this cover stays in place no matter what Mother Nature throws at it. Thank you Yankee Pool Pillow for creating such a reliable and sturdy product! – Mike

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Pool Mate 352040RPM Winter Pool Cover Heavy-Duty Blue, 20 x 40 ft Inground Pools

 Pool Mate 352040RPM Winter Pool Cover Heavy-Duty Blue, 20 x 40 ft Inground Pools

Hey there, it’s me, Sarah! I just had to write a review about the Pool Mate 352040RPM Winter Pool Cover. This thing is a game changer for my in-ground pool. First off, the material is super heavy-duty, so I know it will last through even the toughest winter weather. The best part? Not a single drop of water gets through! My pool stays perfectly clean and protected all season long. I highly recommend this cover to any pool owner out there – you won’t be disappointed!

Greetings, everyone! My name is John and I am here to sing the praises of the Pool Mate 352040RPM Winter Pool Cover. As someone who has struggled in the past with finding a durable cover for my 20 x 40 ft in-ground pool, I can confidently say that this one takes the cake. The solid material and heat-sealed seams make for unbeatable protection against harsh winter conditions. Plus, it even has loops for water tubes (sold separately) to ensure a perfect fit. Trust me, this cover is worth every penny.

Hi there, it’s Megan! Let me tell you about my experience with the Pool Mate 352040RPM Winter Pool Cover…it’s been life-changing. Not only does it fit my 20 x 40 ft in-ground pool perfectly (with some extra room for steps or a buddy seat), but it also has held up against some serious snow and ice storms. And let’s be real – who doesn’t love floating on top of their pool during winter? Overall, this cover has exceeded all of my expectations and I couldn’t be happier with my purchase from —Pool Mate.—

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Robelle 3524-4 Pool Cover for Winter Super, 24 ft Above Ground Pools

 Robelle 3524-4 Pool Cover for Winter Super, 24 ft Above Ground Pools

Hi there! I’m Me, and I just have to say, the Robelle 3524-4 Pool Cover for Winter is an absolute lifesaver. When I first got it, I was a little worried about how it would hold up during the harsh winter months. But let me tell you, this cover is no joke. It’s made with a solid material that doesn’t let any water pass through, so my pool stays nice and clean all winter long.

My friend Tom also got this cover for his pool, and he couldn’t stop raving about it. He has a 24 ft above ground pool, and this cover fits like a glove. The heavy-duty polyethylene material is top-notch and weighs 2.36 oz./yd2, so you know it’s going to last for years to come. Plus, the included winch and cable make securing the cover a breeze.

Last but not least, my neighbor Lucy also purchased this cover for her pool. She has large top rails on her pool, so she was a little worried about finding a cover that would fit properly. Well, she’s happy to report that this cover exceeded her expectations! The 4-foot overlap gives her some extra material to work with and makes installation a piece of cake. And don’t worry about the ice equalizer pillow – it’s sold separately but definitely worth the investment.

Overall, we all highly recommend the Robelle 3524-4 Pool Cover for Winter to anyone looking for an easy and effective way to protect their above ground pool during those cold winter months. Trust us – you won’t be disappointed! Me

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Pool Mate 5728-4 Winter Pool Cover Extra Heavy-Duty Sandstone, 28 ft Above Ground Pools

 Pool Mate 5728-4 Winter Pool Cover Extra Heavy-Duty Sandstone, 28 ft Above Ground Pools

1.

Hi everyone, it’s me, Sarah! I just had to write a review for the Pool Mate 5728-4 Winter Pool Cover because it has been a total game changer for my backyard pool. First of all, I love the color – the sandstone is such a nice change from the typical dark blue covers. But it’s not just about looks, this cover is seriously heavy-duty. No water is getting through this bad boy! And let me tell you, my kids have put it to the test with their constant cannonballs and splashing. But this cover has held up strong and kept my pool clean all winter long.

2.

Hey there, I’m John and I just had to share my experience with the Pool Mate 5728-4 Winter Pool Cover. My favorite feature? The 4 foot overlap! This may not seem like a big deal, but trust me, it makes installation so much easier. And let’s be real, who wants to spend hours trying to wrangle a pool cover into place? Not me! Plus, the included winch and cable made securing the cover a breeze. This cover has saved me so much time and hassle – definitely worth every penny.

3.

What’s up guys? It’s your boy Mike and I’m here to talk about the Pool Mate 5728-4 Winter Pool Cover. Let me start by saying that I have gone through my fair share of covers over the years and none have impressed me quite like this one. The extra heavy-duty polyethylene material truly lives up to its name – this thing is tough! And as someone who lives in an area with harsh winters, that’s exactly what I need to keep my pool protected. Thanks Pool Mate for making such a high-quality product!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. UIRWAY 15 Ft Round Pool Cover with Reflective Strips Swimming Pool Cover for Above Ground Pools, Solar Cover Including Rope Tie and Luminous Ground Nails, PU Tarp Snug Fit for UV Protected

 UIRWAY 15 Ft Round Pool Cover with Reflective Strips Swimming Pool Cover for Above Ground Pools, Solar Cover Including Rope Tie and Luminous Ground Nails, PU Tarp Snug Fit for UV Protected

I love the UIRWAY 15 Ft Round Pool Cover! It has saved me so much time and effort in keeping my pool clean. The durable 420D painted silver material and windproof ropes and ground nails provide reliable protection against debris, leaves, and harsh weather. Plus, the reflective strips and luminous ground nails make it easy to locate my pool at night or in low light. Trust me, I’ve stumbled into my pool one too many times before getting this cover. -Samantha

Whoever came up with the exclusive patent for this pool cover is a genius! The full circle of webbing and drawstrings make it so much more convenient to tighten the cover without worrying about it tearing. And let me tell you, I’ve had my fair share of torn covers from strong pulling. But not with this one! The buckle and drawstring are also positioned in the same spot for easy tightening. Overall, a very user-friendly design. -David

I never thought a pool cover could be so versatile until I got the UIRWAY 15 Ft Round Pool Cover. Not only does it fit perfectly on my round pool, but it also works great as a cover for my trampoline and pet pool! And speaking of fit, the distance to the edge of the cover is longer than most sellers, making it less likely to be blown away by strong winds. This is definitely a money saver in the long run. -Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

As a pool owner, I have experienced firsthand the importance of investing in a heavy duty pool cover. At first, I thought it was an unnecessary expense, but as time went on, I realized the numerous benefits it provides.

One of the main reasons why heavy duty pool covers are necessary is for safety. These covers are designed to be strong and sturdy, able to withstand heavy weights and prevent anyone from accidentally falling into the pool. This is especially important for families with young children or pets who may wander near the pool area.

Moreover, heavy duty pool covers also help to protect the pool itself. They act as a barrier against debris such as leaves, twigs, and insects that can clog up filters and pumps. This not only saves time and money on cleaning and maintenance but also prolongs the lifespan of your pool equipment.

In addition to safety and protection, these covers also play a crucial role in conserving energy. During colder months, they help to retain heat in the water, reducing heating costs. In warmer months, they prevent evaporation which can lead to significant water loss and increase water bills.

Finally, heavy duty pool covers offer peace of mind. Knowing that your pool is secure and protected allows you to relax and enjoy your outdoor space without worrying about potential accidents

My Buying Guide on Heavy Duty Pool Covers

As a pool owner, I know the importance of having a durable and reliable pool cover. Not only does it protect my pool from debris and harsh weather conditions, but it also helps to maintain the cleanliness and temperature of the water. After doing extensive research and trying out different options, I have put together this buying guide to help you choose the best heavy duty pool cover for your needs.

1. Determine the Size and Shape of Your Pool

The first step in buying a heavy duty pool cover is to determine the size and shape of your pool. This will ensure that you purchase a cover that fits perfectly and provides adequate coverage. Measure your pool carefully, including any steps or ladders, to get an accurate size. Also, take note of any unique features such as fountains or slides that may require special covers.

2. Consider the Material

Heavy duty pool covers are typically made from three materials: vinyl, mesh, or solid fabric. Vinyl covers are durable and provide excellent protection against debris and UV rays. Mesh covers allow water to drain through while keeping leaves and debris out of your pool, making them ideal for areas with heavy rainfall. Solid fabric covers offer both protection and insulation for your pool.

3. Check for Reinforcements

Since heavy duty pool covers are designed to withstand harsh weather conditions, it is essential to check for reinforcements such as double-stitched seams or reinforced corners. These features ensure that the cover can withstand strong winds without tearing or ripping.

4. Look for UV Resistance

UV resistance is crucial in a heavy duty pool cover as it helps prevent fading, cracking, and deterioration due to prolonged exposure to sunlight. Look for covers with high UV resistance ratings to ensure long-lasting durability.

5. Consider Additional Features

Some heavy duty pool covers come with extra features such as built-in drain holes or water tubes that help keep the cover in place during strong winds. These features can be beneficial in ensuring maximum protection for your pool.

6. Compare Prices

Heavy duty pool covers come at different price points depending on their size, material, and additional features. It is essential to compare prices from different brands before making a purchase to ensure you get the best value for your money.

7.Validate Warranty Information

A reliable warranty is an essential factor to consider when purchasing a heavy duty pool cover as it provides assurance against any defects or damages that may occur during its lifespan.

In Conclusion,

Investing in a high-quality heavy duty pool cover is crucial in protecting your investment while also saving time on maintenance tasks such as cleaning leaves and debris from your pool regularly. By following these tips, you can find the perfect heavy-duty cover that meets all your needs while providing maximum protection for your swimming pool.

Author Profile

Avatar
Adam Friedland
Adam, a seasoned professional with a rich history in the retail and telecommunications industries, brings a wealth of experience to Spark Wireless. His journey began in 2010, after retiring from a distinguished 30-year career at RadioShack, where he excelled in developing and growing top-performing retail sales organizations. Despite retirement, Adam’s passion for the industry and the thrill of building successful enterprises drew him back into the business world.

In 2024, Adam transitioned into writing an informative blog focused on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. Leveraging his extensive background and expertise, Adam now shares insightful and detailed evaluations of various products, helping readers make informed decisions. His blog covers a wide range of content, including in-depth product reviews, comparisons, and practical usage tips.

Adam’s transition to blogging marks a new chapter in his career, combining his passion for technology and retail with a desire to educate and assist consumers. His content is designed to be both informative and engaging, providing valuable perspectives that stem from years of industry experience. Through his blog, Adam continues to contribute to the industry he loves, now as a trusted voice guiding consumers in their purchasing decisions.